owking South Florida Jews mark a dark anniversary. For many, it’s sparked a reawakening of faith
As Jews across South Florida gather this month to celebrate the High Holy Daysowking, the tragedies of a terror attack and escalating war in the Middle East loom over the festivities: There are painful memories of a horrific day but also a stronger sense of unity and, for many, a return to faith.
October 7 marks one year since Hamas militants stormed into Israel on brutal raids that left 1,200 people dead and another 240 taken hostage, sparking a war in Gaza with no end in sight. The anniversary of the attack falls right in between two major Jewish holidays — Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year, and Yom Kippur, the Day of Atonement and the holiest day of the Jewish calendar.
“Since October 7, it’s been the most difficult year for most of us to be a Jew,” said Rabbi Gayle Pomerantz, senior rabbi at Temple Beth Sholom in Miami Beach and president of the Rabbinic Association of Greater Miami. “I know it certainly is the most difficult year to be a Jew in my lifetime.”
“It’s kind of an awareness that’s just going to be in the air we breathe,” she said. “All of us recognize this moment.”
Commemorations will take place in synagogues throughout South Florida. On Sunday, the Jewish Federation of Broward County will host a communty-wide event. Two major ones are planned on Monday, one hosted by the Greater Miami Jewish Federation at Pomerantz’s synagogue and the other by the city of Miami Beach.
The deadliest attack committed against Jews since the Holocaust has produced profound impacts far beyond the borders of Israel.
The terror attack on innocent civilians triggered an ongoing, escalating war in the Middle East that has left tens of thousands of Palestinians in the Hamas-run Gaza Strip dead. It has sparked continuing protests from both sides across the United States and a surge in reports of hate crimes tied to the conflict. It’s also had ripple effects on the political landscape, from Miami to Tallahassee and Washington, D.C.
The anger and pain have been keenly felt in South Florida, home to one of the largest Jewish communities in the nation and residents with deep ties to Israel through faith, families and culture.
“The Jewish community is teeny tiny, so we’re all one or two degrees of separation from each other,” said Audra Berg, president & CEO of the Jewish Federation of Broward County. “And there’s a very large Israeli population in South Florida.”
Many Jews are feeling a stronger sense of unity within their own community since the attacks, said Jeffrey Levin, executive vice president of the Greater Miami Jewish Federation.
“We Jews are a famously cantankerous people, but Hamas has done more to unite us than we were before. That’s not to say that there aren’t outliers ... but by and large, the Jewish community here in the United States stands even more firmly behind Israel than it did on October 6th.”
Steven Brodie, who visited Israel before and after the attacks, remembers waking up on October 7 to a red alert — a type of mobile alert that notifies him whenever there’s a warning of any kind in Israel.
“I woke up and saw thousands of alerts that morning,” said Brodie, a prominent Florida lawyer and vice chair of the board of the Greater Miami Jewish Federation. “I remember a state of disbelief ... while I understood there was not peace, I didn’t fully understand how evil humanity could be.”
Broward federation president Berg sees the upcoming commemorations as opportunity to look forward.
“This is both a chance to mourn with with the Israeli people, together with our community, but also to feel some inspiration about the future and to look with hope to the future,” she said. “It’s not very Jewish to just focus on what’s bad. We also like to look at what’s good.”
South Florida springs into actionIn the months since, South Florida has seen an surge of support for the Jewish community and Israel from elected officials, businesses and residents.
Jewish and non-Jewish organizations have raised millions of dollars for humanitarian aid for Israelis. Just two days after Oct 7, 2023, the Greater Miami Jewish Federation organized a rally in Miami Beach with thousands in attendance, kicking off a campaign that raised over $30 million to support Israelis impacted by the war.
“We’ve been totally blessed by the outpouring of support here in Miami,” said Levin.
While antisemitic incidents have increased throughout the nation, according to the Anti-Defamation League and other advocacy groups, Levin says South Florida is fortunate to have had a more positive experience.
“American Jews were stunned at the explosion of antisemitism in the wake of October 7,” Levin said. “Jews in South Florida did not have that experience. We were enveloped by support of the community, and that continues to this day. I often say that we live here in Miami on an island of love in a sea of hate.”
The majority of state and local lawmakers have been vocal supporters of Israel. Just weeks after the attack, the Miami-Dade County commission passed resolutions supporting Israel and condemning Hamas. The city of Miami Beach sent city firefighters to fill in for first responders in Israel who had been called to military service. The Florida Legislature called for a special session allowing lawmakers to express their support for Israel, and eventually passed legislation that defines antisemitism.
Gov. Ron DeSantis, who has vowed to be the most “pro-Israel governor in America,” awarded thousands of dollars to support Jewish organizations in Florida and sent rescue flights evacuating about 700 Americans from Israel immediately following Oct. 7. His administration has also donated aid and healthcare supplies as well as drones, weapons and ammunition to Israel. The state university system also pursued a controversial crackdown on what it defined as “antisemitic” and “anti-Israel” content in Florida’s public universities.
“I think we feel very fortunate that the Jewish community in Florida is supported by the political establishment, by school boards and police... All of the elements of the political environment in Florida have been very supportive, especially at the university level,” said Broward federation president Berg.
Many local groups have also organized several mission trips to Israel to show their support.
“People come back with renewed strength, with more information, with a better sense of what’s actually happening in Israel and with a deeper commitment,” said Levin, who went with the Miami Federation on various trips to visit the site of the Nova Music Festival, meet with hostage families, IDF soldiers and Israeli leaders.
Seth Wise, annual campaign chair for the Jewish Federation of Broward County, went on a trip to Israel post Oct. 7 to help organize a mobile kitchen for IDF soldiers.
“For me, I wanted to do something where I could really go and feel like I was helping, not just shaking hands, but actually lending a hand,” he said.
Wise was a part of a group that sponsored barbecues for soldiers across Israel and on the Gaza border. He said it was important for him and others to show gratitude for troops protecting Israeli citizens.
“Look, we’re a small group, we’re 10 people. We’re making you hamburgers and just want to show you some gratitude, but we represent millions of people, Jews and non Jews around the world who are grateful for what you’re doing. It was incredibly rewarding.”
Protests in the wake of warIsrael’s retaliation to the attack, however, has since become a source of counter-protests and ongoing friction in Florida. An initial wave of pro-Palestinian protests on college campuses in Florida were met with hostility and anger from lawmakers, who took a “law and order” approach to shutting them down, said Ray Rodrigues, chancellor of the State University System in an press conference earlier this year.
The DeSantis administration ordered local law enforcement and the Florida Highway Patrol to intervene in the protests, and called for state universities to disband campus groups with ties to the national Students for Justice in Palestine organization. Dozens of students protesters have been arrested and the protests have sparked a national conversation about the balance of free speech and safety on campuses.
In Miami Beach, home to a large Jewish population, city officials passed protest restrictions. In the city of Doral, Mayor Christi Fraga faced immediate backlash for advocating for a resolution that called for a ceasefire between Israel and Gaza. Fraga later walked back the largely symbolic measure.
Supporters of a Palestinian state, even those who condemned the Hamas attack, say there’s been a double standard when it comes to protests and attacks on civilians.
“The history of this conflict does not start on Oct 7,” said Lana Shehadeh, who was born and raised in Parkland, but was living in West Bank during the attack.
Shehadeh, an assistant professor of political science at the Arab American University in the West Bank, said that since the war broke out, the majority of Palestinians have lost all hope for any sort of resolution or even a ceasefire. She described the difficulty of living in a years-long occupation, where she says spontaneous raids, interrogations and beatings by Isreali soldiers are a common occurrence.
“I heard people say, I just wanna die, and we’re over. It’s over. Students, half of them aren’t registered. Nobody cares to finish their degrees. The amount of pessimism is just so sad, so sad.”
And the loss of life, she said, has “been unimaginable.” An estimated 41,000-plus Palestinians have been killed in the Gaza Strip, most of them not Hamas militants.
“If you were to tell me a number like that in October or November, I would be laughing, because I would think that there’s no way the international community would be comfortable with that amount of people being killed in response to any kind of attack,” she said. “Nobody’s condoning what happened on October 7, but by no means has the response been proportional.”
Echoing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, many South Florida Jews say a terrorized nation has a right and duty to defend its citizens. Wise, annual campaign chair of the Jewish Federation of Broward County, said he feels that many Jews feel frustration over the amount of backlash against the response.
“No country, no army, no leaders are infallible. But the perception is, at least from my standpoint, that there’s a general effort to try and, as ugly as these things can be, to do as good a job as you can to protect civilians and somehow that piece has gotten lost,” he said.
Despite the controversy, many Jewish leaders who spoke to the Miami Herald said they are heartened by an unexpected wave of commitment to the Jewish faith.
“There has been this phenomenon called ‘the surge’ .... where Jews who have in the past been disaffiliated or unaffiliated have have said, ‘I want to step up and and be a part of this community and learn more and participate,” said Rabbi Pomerantz. That also shows, she said, in a higher rate of applications to Jewish classes, schools and universities.
“We have an introduction to Judaism class in Miami for people wanting to learn more about Judaism or convert -- it’s the largest enrollment we’ve ever had,” she said.
At Rosh Hashanah service this year, Pomerantz opened the service with a prayer to reflect this year’s sentiment around the war: “May the curses of the past year be finished. May the blessings of the new year begin. And I think that’s really the sentiment with which we enter the holidays.”
This story was produced with financial support from Trish and Dan Bell and from donors comprising the South Florida Jewish and Muslim Communities, in partnership with Journalism Funding Partners. The Miami Herald maintains full editorial control of this work.
This story was originally published October 6, 2024owking, 5:30 AM.